Australians have long flocked to Fiji, drawn by easy flights, big resorts and kids’ clubs that start early and finish late. Meanwhile, New Zealanders have quietly kept the Cook Islands under wraps, treating it as their go-to island escape for slow days, calm lagoons and stress-free family travel. Both destinations sit firmly in the South Pacific dream category. Both promise warm welcomes, tropical scenery and memorable family experiences. But when it comes to travelling with kids, which one wins the Fiji vs Cook Islands debate?
If you want the short answer before diving deeper, here’s how Fiji vs Cook Islands compare for family holidays.
| Category | Fiji | Cook Islands |
|---|---|---|
| Best for | Easy, resort-style family holidays | Relaxed, slow-paced family travel |
| Family resorts | Large resorts with kids clubs and pools | Smaller resorts, apartments & villas |
| Kids’ clubs | Excellent, often included. | Limited to a few resorts in Rarotonga |
| Beaches | Beautiful (some are average), sometimes tidal | Beautiful, calm lagoon, ideal for kids |
| Getting around | Mostly stay at resort | Easy island exploration |
| Cost & value | Can get pricey for big-name resorts but package deals are available | Better value for longer stays |
| Cultural experiences | Organised, high-energy | Authentic, everyday island life |
| Ideal kids’ age | Toddlers to younger kids | School-age kids & teens |
| Overall vibe | Fun, lively, effortless | Calm, uncrowded, connected |
Here’s how Fiji vs Cook Islands really stacks up for family holidays
The overall vibe
Fiji is energetic, friendly and purpose-built for families. Resorts run like well-oiled machines, kids are celebrated everywhere, and entertainment is constant. It’s a destination designed to make parents’ lives easier.
The Cook Islands feel very different. Life moves more slowly here. The pace is gentle, the islands are uncrowded, and family time naturally replaces structured entertainment. It’s less about ticking boxes and more about being present together.
If you want a holiday that feels effortless and lively, Fiji delivers. If you’re craving a reset and fewer schedules, the Cook Islands shine.
Family accommodation and resorts
This is where Fiji really flexes its family-holiday muscles. Many resorts are built specifically with kids in mind, offering large kids’ clubs, water parks, kids programs, nanny services and daily activities. Parents can genuinely relax knowing there’s always something organised.
Accommodation in the Cook Islands is smaller and more personal. Think beachfront apartments, villas and low-rise resorts rather than sprawling complexes. Some resorts offer kids’ programs in Rarotonga, but the focus is more on shared family experiences than full-scale childcare.
Families with toddlers and younger kids often find Fiji easier. Families with older kids or teens often prefer the freedom and calm of the Cook Islands.
Getting around and ease of travel
Fiji holidays tend to centre around the resort. Transfers are organised, and many of the nicer resorts are in more remote locations, which means less moving around once you arrive.
The Cook Islands, particularly Rarotonga, are wonderfully easy to explore. You can drive around the island in under an hour, hire a car or scooter, and dip in and out of beaches, cafés and snorkelling spots without much effort. It’s a little more effort to reach the outer islands, though.
If you like staying put and letting the resort do the work, Fiji suits. If you enjoy exploring at your own pace, the Cook Islands feel refreshingly simple.
Beaches and swimming with kids
Both destinations are beautiful, but they offer different beach experiences.
In Fiji, beaches can be stunning, but be aware that not all of the big-name resorts are on beautiful beaches, particularly if you haven’t ventured off the main island to the outer islands. Some are just ‘okay’ – still nice, but definitely not the white sand and blue water that you saw on Instagram. Some are also affected by tides. Many resorts compensate with protected swimming areas or man-made lagoons, which are great for younger kids.
The Cook Islands are famous for calm, shallow lagoons with clear water, especially around Rarotonga and Aitutaki. Snorkelling straight off the beach is common, and the swimming conditions feel naturally family-friendly.
Families who love easy, worry-free ocean time often lean towards the Cook Islands.
Cost and overall value
Fiji resorts are expensive, but you can often get package deals on Luxury Escapes and find cheaper flight deals. If you’re a little savvy when researching your trip, Fiji can be good value for money. Many people get caught off guard by how expensive the resort restaurants are, and it can often be better value to get a package deal that includes meals and kids’ clubs to make budgeting straightforward.
The Cook Islands can be slightly more expensive to get to from Australia, but once you’re there, costs are easier to manage. Self-catering accommodation and local eateries help keep daily expenses down, especially for longer stays.
Fiji works well for short, all-inclusive-style holidays. The Cook Islands suit families staying longer and wanting flexibility. For me (as a parent who doesn’t need kids’ club), the Cook Islands wins overall in terms of value-for-money.
Culture and connection
Fiji’s cultural experiences are vibrant and high-energy, with organised village visits, performances and constant interaction with resort staff. It’s engaging and fun, particularly for younger kids.
The Cook Islands offer a quieter but deeply authentic cultural experience. Local markets, island nights, storytelling and everyday interactions create meaningful moments that tend to stick with older children.
Both offer rich culture, just delivered in very different ways.
So, which one gets family holidays right?
The truth is, both do. Just for different families and different stages of life.
Choose Fiji if you love resort-style living and want everything organised for you. Fiji is also a good choice if it’s your first time holidaying overseas with the kids.
Choose the Cook Islands if your family values slow travel, independence, calm beaches and shared experiences over schedules.
Fiji has perfected family-friendly tourism. The Cook Islands have mastered family-friendly living. The right choice comes down to how your family likes to travel.
Fiji vs Cook Islands: Frequently Asked Questions
Both are excellent for families, but they suit different travel styles. Fiji is better for families wanting all-inclusive resorts, kids’ clubs and minimal planning. The Cook Islands are better for families who prefer slower travel, calm beaches and more independence.
Yes, especially for school-age kids and teenagers. The Cook Islands offer calm lagoons, safe swimming, snorkelling straight off the beach and a relaxed pace that works well for families who enjoy spending time together.
Fiji is one of the most family-friendly destinations in the South Pacific, but it can be expensive if you don’t shop around for deals. With purpose-built resorts and excellent kids’ clubs, it’s particularly popular with Australian families travelling with younger children.
Flights to Fiji are often cheaper, but the cost of accommodation and food drives the overall holiday budget up. The Cook Islands can cost more to get to from Australia, but day-to-day expenses are easier to manage, especially if you self-cater.
Fiji is generally easier with toddlers thanks to large resorts, childcare options, shallow resort pools and organised activities. The Cook Islands suit families with toddlers too, but require a bit more self-management.
The Cook Islands often appeal more to families with teenagers who enjoy snorkelling, independence and exploring. Fiji can still work well, particularly if teens enjoy resort activities and social environments.
Still deciding? Our Fiji and Cook Islands destination guides will provide some inspiration:
This article contains affiliate links to products. We may receive a commission for purchases made through these links.
Where to next?
📌 Save this article to Pinterest so you’ll have it handy when planning your own trip.
Let me know what you think!